Deficit
Lakoff, 1975
Main features of women's language
-Hedges and fillers 'sort of' 'kind of'
-Empty adjectives 'divine' 'adorable'
-Super-polite forms 'would you mind'
-Apologise more
-Speak less frequently
-Avoid coarse language
-Tag questions
-Hyper correct grammar and pronunciation (women perceive language to be inspirational)
-Indirect requests : 'I'm so thirsty' - asking for a drink. (pragmatics)
-Speak in italics (use tone of voice to emphasis certain words)
Criticisms of Lakoff
-Since her work there has been a lot of changes between the genders.
- Her work lacks statistics
Jenny Chesire, 1983
(supports Lakoff's idea of 'hyper-correct grammar and pronunciation)
looked at certain grammatical variations in the speech of young children and found that boys used more non-standard English than girls.
Difference
(idea that women and men speak differently)
Deborah Tannen , 1990
-Identifies gender differences in terms of competitiveness (male) and co-operative (female).
"There are gender difference in ways of speaking and we need to identify and understand them"
Contrasts to differences
Status vs Support - men use language and dominance. Women are likely to support and agree.
Independence vs Intimacy - Men use language to show they don't need to rely on others. Women can connect with others.
Advice vs understanding
Information vs feelings
Orders vs Proposals
Conflict vs Compromise
No comments:
Post a Comment